Homeowner guide

How do I set an asking price when I owe more than my home is worth?

Use local sale evidence to estimate what a buyer will pay and written payoff figures to estimate the gap. Your mortgage balance and the amount a creditor might accept answer different questions.

Build a short list of comparable sales

Ask your agent for nearby closed sales with similar size, condition, lot, location and property type. Look closely at the interior condition of each comparable. An updated house across town might offer weaker evidence than a similar house on a nearby street with the same deferred maintenance.

Request any investor guidance

Ask the servicer whether its investor provides price guidance and how the agent should request it. For a Fannie Mae loan, its suggested list price is guidance. An offer at that price can still require further review. Write the date and source beside any proposed number so an older opinion does not get mistaken for a new decision.

Keep the pricing and payoff worksheets separate

For example, an estimated market price of $275,000 and dated payoffs totaling $284,000 already suggest a gap before selling expenses. Raising the list price to the payoff amount will only help if the market supports it. Ask the agent to show how each plausible sale price changes the estimated proceeds.

Choose when to revisit the price

Record showing activity, written feedback, competing sales and offers. Before changing the advertised price, ask the servicer or agent whether the applicable process requires updated guidance or a new submission. Keep a dated copy of the market evidence behind the change.

Sources

Sources reviewed November 18, 2026.

Published by the Nilsen Team, eXp Realty. Sources and editorial policy.