Do I actually need a short sale?
Compare the amount that would remain after selling expenses with dated payoff statements for every mortgage. A recent mortgage statement and an online home value are only starting points.
Sources checked November 18, 2026Step 1. Price the home as it stands
Ask for comparable recent sales and a range of likely prices that reflects the home’s current condition. If a buyer would need to replace a roof or requires a closing credit, run a second estimate using those terms. Ask for a written seller net sheet so you can see what changed.
Step 2. Get figures for the same closing date
Request a payoff for the proposed settlement date for the first mortgage and any home-equity loan or line. Ask the closing attorney to identify additional amounts that must be resolved. Interest through settlement, unpaid charges, taxes and association balances can move the answer. Check which costs the net sheet already includes to avoid counting the same item twice.
A worked example
Suppose a buyer offers $245,000 and estimated selling costs are $15,000. That leaves $230,000. If two dated payoffs total $238,000, the estimated gap is $8,000. An owner who can cover the gap might close through a conventional sale. If the gap cannot be covered, the owner can ask whether one or more creditors will approve a reduced payoff. The figures illustrate arithmetic only.
Refresh the estimate before accepting terms
A new offer, delayed closing or additional lien can change which parties need to agree. Ask the attorney what must be paid or released, and ask each affected servicer what it needs to consider the revised deal. A price above the first mortgage balance can still leave a closing shortfall.
Sources for this guide
Related reading
Published by the Nilsen Team, eXp Realty. Sources and editorial policy.