What if the servicer thinks my house is worth more than buyers will pay?
Ask whether the applicable program accepts a value dispute. A focused packet explaining a factual error or a meaningful difference between properties is more useful than a bare request to lower the number.
Identify the number being questioned
Ask whether you received list-price guidance, a request for a higher purchase price, a proposed minimum net, or another valuation figure. Record its date and the response deadline. An old price or a number relayed secondhand may send your agent down the wrong path.
Gather evidence a reviewer can evaluate
Ask your agent for relevant closed sales and a plain explanation of differences. For a property-condition issue, use dated photographs and, where available, a contractor’s written estimate identifying the work. Distinguish a documented defect from a buyer’s preference for upgrades. Keep account numbers and unrelated personal information out of the package.
Use the right channel
Fannie Mae describes a formal value-dispute workflow in HomePath for Short Sales. Ask the servicer or listing agent who may submit the request for your case, which fields or evidence are required, and how to track its status. Other investors may use different channels.
Protect the other deadlines
A value review can interrupt an offer review. Ask your agent to update the buyer and document any contract extension. If a foreclosure sale is scheduled, separately confirm its status with the trustee and seek legal help promptly. A dispute receipt alone is no evidence that court or sale dates changed.
Sources
Sources reviewed November 18, 2026.
Published by the Nilsen Team, eXp Realty. Sources and editorial policy.